|
Fragile
C Syndrome: To Test or Not to Test
by Tillie Young, MS and Beth A. Pletcher, MD, May
1998
While fragile X syndrome is the most
common known inherited cause of mental retardation, it is frequently
undiagnosed and unrecognized. It affects about 1 in 1200 males and
1 in 2000 females (compared with an incidence of Down syndrome of
1 in 700). The degree of mental retardation ranges from mild to
severe with males more often severely affected than females. Some
of the reasons this condition is frequently not considered in the
child with developmental delay are:
- Many clinicians focus on the clinical features
associated with fragile X. These features are usually subtle,
may even be absent or may not become apparent until adolescence.
While the presence of mental disabilities is consistent in males,
shyness and autistic behaviors may or may not be present. Hypotonia
and associated joint laxity are nonspecific findings as are
recurrent ear infections or seizures. Testicular enlargement
is evident only in post-adolescent males.
- Family history is often negative in children
diagnosed with fragile X syndrome and is helpful only when positive
for maternally inherited mental retardation. Family history
is generally more useful when deciding whether or not to test
a female with mild learning problems.
Making the diagnosis of fragile X provides
a number of benefits to the patient as well as the extended family.
Individualized educational programs may be positively influenced
by knowing this diagnosis since behavioral and cognitive profiles
in children with fragile X are somewhat consistent. These may serve
as a reference point for the Child Study Team without losing sight
of the child's individual needs. Medical management for recognized
complications such as mitral valve prolapse is clear and optimal
pharmacologic management for ADD, ADHD, OCD or anxiety disorders
is often dependent upon making a correct diagnosis. Parents may
go on to have a number of affected children before they realize
they are at risk for fragile X. Furthermore, maternal aunts, sisters,
cousins and other relatives may be completely unaware of their reproductive
risks if fragile X has never been considered. Then the question
becomes, who to test and how to test:
- All males with unexplained, significant developmental
delay should be screened for fragile X as well as any other
chromosomal variation. Boys are often identified by significant
speech delay with or without ADHD. For males selected in this
way about 1 in 20-25 will be positive. The pick-up rate is higher
for males with obvious clinical and behavioral features or with
a suggestive family history. In this same group about 1 in 30-50
boys will have a detectable chromosome variation (deletion,
duplication, marker or sex chromosome variation).
- Selected females should also be screened both
for fragile X and chromosome abnormalities. While about one
third of females with a fully expanded fragile X gene are of
normal intelligence, one third have learning disabilities and
one third are mildly retarded. If there is a suggestive family
history, any girl with learning disabilities should clearly
be tested for fragile X. Any woman with a known family member
with fragile X who is at risk for inheriting the gene should
be offered screening. A girl with learning disabilities associated
with short stature, dysmorphic features and/or minor or major
birth defects should be screened for chromosomal abnormalities
before testing for fragile X.
- No one should have cytogenetic testing for
fragile X in 1998! The optimal way to diagnose fragile X is
by molecular technologies (preferably using both PCR and southern
blot analyses). Testing is usually done on blood collected in
purple top EDTA tubes whereas cytogenetic studies are done on
blood drawn in a green top Na heparin tube. Therefore, to do
both analyses one should ideally obtain blood in two 5cc purple
top and one 5-10cc green top tubes.
- The region just adjacent to (upstream of) the
fragile X gene or FMR1 gene has a series of CGG triplet repeats
with the normal number ranging from 29-40 repeats. Individuals
with more than 60 repeats are considered to have an unstable
or premutation size region that is susceptible to even greater
expansion during meiosis. If one thinks of meiosis as a Xeroxing
process, a premutation may lead to reduplication of the CGG
region which, for unknown reasons, occurs exclusively in egg
cells. Normal males may carry a premutation size region but
usually pass it on unchanged to their normal daughters who are
subsequently at risk for having affected sons.
- Fragile X syndrome occurs when the triplet
repeats exceed 200 resulting in methylation or switching off
of the FMR1 gene. If you no longer make this gene product you
are affected with fragile X. Females who have two X chromosomes
are able to make some of the FMR1 gene product and this is why
they are less often or more mildly affected.
- Although some laboratories are using only a
single methodology, interpretation of the molecular test results
is an art and frequently requires having both PCR and southern
blot results for optimal diagnostic accuracy. This is especially
true for females who may be carriers or have a full gene expansion.
We have encountered numerous instances where a misdiagnosis
has been made using only on methodology.
Several resources are available on
a national basis to help families dealing with the diagnosis and
management of fragile X. Both of the groups listed below not only
provide support, but are committed to public and professional education.
If you have any fragile X issues that we can help you with please
feel free to contact Tillie Young, MS who serves as the coordinator
of the Fragile X Diagnostic and Treatment Center here at UMDNJ (973)
972-3300. For more information you may turn to:
|